Mirror Football
13 October 2026
Jamie Carragher believes he hasn't been a hypocrite on the Manchester City scandal after comments saying he would ‘rather cheat and win’ resurfaced online.
The Liverpool icon has been at the forefront of the coverage regarding Manchester City being found guilty by an independent commission of 114 Premier League charges.
He has suggested that City should be seriously punished should their appeal fail. Despite that, some fans have reminded Carragher of some telling comments that he made about cheating.
Featuring on the Diary of CEO podcast back in 2022, the former Liverpool star suggested: “For me when I played, I’d rather cheat and win.”
That comment was picked up by talkSPORT, with Jim White and Simon Jordan debating Carragher’s claim, with the former Crystal Palace chairman accusing the Sky Sports pundit of hypocrisy.
Get our comprehensive football coverage, with news, updates, opinions, analysis and everything that matters to you, straight to your inbox.
To get it, it's a quick and easy one-two:
2. Enter your email and hit Subscribe
But Carragher has now hit back and replied on social media claiming that he would only be trying to deceive on the pitch - not off of it.
He wrote: “No it’s not hypocritical. I’m talking about my striker diving for a penalty, me stopping a ball going over the line with my hand! I’m not talking about 900M in fake sponsorship over a number of years.”
Discussing the clip of Carragher, which quickly went viral on social media, Jordan said: “He’ll feel that perhaps he shouldn’t have said that because it wasn’t totally necessary for Jamie to have said that. I actually spoke to Jamie over the weekend because I see Piers having a go at him on social media and told him not to rise to it.
“I think it doesn’t alter the fact that what he’s saying about Man City has resonance. Most people in life are hypocrites, they are, they just might not admit it. And he’s been caught in a hypocritical moment where he’s been a hypocrite.
“That doesn't alter the veracity or the efficacy of what he’s saying. All of us are being constantly put in the situation where we have to talk about Manchester City because it’s constantly part of the media cycle.
“So you’ve got all these people who are trying to top one another by saying the most extreme thing. It’s not about being right sometimes, it’s about being first and that’s a tragedy of the news cycles that we live in.
“Notwithstanding that, Jamie’s caught himself in a moment where he’s said something and it will be interesting to see how he finds his way out of that if indeed he’s challenged by it because they’ll take the micky out of him on Sky for it, won’t they?
“But I don’t think it alters what he’s saying about Man City just because he’s being a hypocrite, it doesn’t mean that necessarily his point of view about Man City being sanctioned and brought to book and the consequences of their behaviour needing to be visited on them in a timely fashion.”
Join our WhatsApp community and receive your daily dose of Mirror Football content. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice
Article by Mirror Football. GoalingBreak shows the text for easier reading: all rights remain with the publisher.
Read the original →